Few things annoy a subcontractor more than a payment arriving lighter than expected because of a contra charge they didn't see coming. Some are fair. Many aren't, or can't be backed up. Either way, they're much easier to deal with when you have your own records.
What is a contra charge?
A contra charge is a deduction from your payment for a cost the contractor says you caused. Typical examples on housing sites:
- Damage to another trade's work (a cut cable, a chipped bath, a holed ceiling)
- Cleaning up waste left on a plot
- Rework by someone else because work was incomplete or defective
- Use of the contractor's plant, materials or labour
- Delays the contractor says you caused
When is a contra charge fair?
| Question | If yes | If no |
|---|---|---|
| Does your subcontract allow deductions for this? | Move on to the evidence | Challenge on contract grounds |
| Were you told before the payment (with a valid pay less notice where needed)? | Check the amount | Challenge on process |
| Is there evidence you caused it? | Check the amount is reasonable | Ask for the evidence |
| Were you given the chance to put it right yourself? | Check the cost | Rework by others usually costs more; say so |
| Is the amount reasonable? | Accept or negotiate | Ask for the breakdown |
How do you challenge a contra charge?
- Ask for the evidence in writing: photos, dates, who found it and the cost breakdown.
- Check your subcontract for the deduction clause and any notice requirements.
- Check the timing: if the contractor intends to pay less than the notified sum, the Construction Act requires a pay less notice in time.
- Answer with your own records: when you finished the plot, its condition, who else worked there afterwards.
- Keep it specific: dispute line by line, not "all contras".
How do you stop contra charges happening?
Most contra charges come down to "who left it like this?". The firm with the better records usually wins that argument, or never has it.
- Photograph the plot when you finish, especially anything the next trade could damage.
- Close tasks with a photo, so there is a timestamped record of completion.
- Log site reports when you find another trade's damage before you start.
- Clear your waste and record that you did.
A worked example
Fictional example. A joinery subcontractor receives a £420 contra charge for "damaged doors, plots 14 to 16". Their fitter had closed each second-fix task with photos of the hung doors two days before the decorator started. The contracts manager sent the photos and task dates back with the query. The charge was withdrawn and re-raised against the right trade.
Where SubbieNow helps
In SubbieNow every task has a messenger and photos with dates, contracts managers can raise site reports with site and plot selection, and contra charges are recorded against the site and shown in sales applications. That means the conversation is about evidence, not memory.
For more on getting the payment side right, read how to write an application for payment that gets paid, or book a demo to see the records SubbieNow keeps.
Frequently asked questions
Can a contractor deduct a contra charge without telling me?
Your subcontract sets the process, but under the Construction Act a payer who intends to pay less than the notified sum must give a valid pay less notice in time. A contra charge that simply appears without notice is worth challenging.
What evidence helps against a contra charge?
Dated photos of the area when you finished, signed handovers, task messages showing who was on the plot, and site reports. Anything that shows the condition you left it in.
Should contra charges appear on my application?
Yes. Listing the contra charges you've been notified of, and marking the ones you dispute, keeps the argument specific and on the record.